News / Profession

Chiropractic in Medicaid: More Good News, Bad News

New Hampshire Keeps Coverage; Michigan's Residents Lose Out
Editorial Staff

On Sept. 4, more than two months into New Hampshire's fiscal year, Governor Craig Benson finally signed a compromise budget, nearly identical to one he vetoed in June. The new budget, which received widespread approval from the state legislature, restores a host of Medicaid services Benson had cut in the original budget - including chiropractic care.

New Hampshire's original budget included cuts to the Medicaid program that removed coverage for chiropractic; eyewear; physical therapy; occupational therapy; adult day care; emergency care; and ambulance rides.1 Although Gov. Benson originally recommended the cuts, and the budget was approved by both houses of the legislature, he then vetoed it for other reasons, including a 10-percent spending increase over the last budget, and heavy reliance on an $83 million federal bailout created by President Bush's latest tax cut.

The compromise budget also restores to previous levels the reimbursement rate in payments to health care providers who provide services under the Medicaid system. Gov. Benson had proposed a 5-percent reduction in Medicaid reimbursements in his original budget.

But as the citizens of New Hampshire rejoice over their ability to keep receiving chiropractic care under Medicaid, Michigan residents are bemoaning the fact that chiropractic services in their state will no longer be covered as of Oct. 1. Approximately 600,000 adults will be affected by the budget cuts, which eliminate Medicaid coverage for chiropractic, dental services, podiatric services and hearing aids.

State officials claim the cuts are drastic, but necessary. According to a spokesperson at the Michigan Department of Community Health, chiropractic and podiatric care account for $7 million in annual spending, while adult dental services account for approximately $20 million per year.

"With the revenue situation as it is, we had to make decisions between the very important and the vital," said Geralyn Lasher. "... there's simply not the funding to cover these services."2,3

According to the Michigan Chiropractic Association, however, the fault lies not with the state legislature, but Gov. Jennifer Granholm, who used her line-item veto privilege to remove chiropractic coverage from the Medicaid program - even though it had been approved by both the House and Senate as part of this year's budget.

For now, Michigan's Medicaid cuts will stay in effect until the end of the fiscal year, in Sept. 2004. However, lawmakers have vowed to work on restoring coverage for at least some services when the legislature resumes its session this fall. Thousands of Michigan DCs and their patients hope chiropractic is on that list.

References

  1. More Medicaid cuts loom for chiropractic. Dynamic Chiropractic, May 19, 2003. www.chiroweb.com/archives/21/11/15.html.
  2. Montemurri P. 600,000 to lose state dental care. Detroit Free Press, Sept. 3, 2003.
  3. Kart J. Routine dental coverage to end in October. Bay City Times, Aug. 30, 2003.


October 2003
print pdf