When I came across the latest findings from the Physicians' Health Study II, evaluating vitamins E and C in the prevention of prostate and total cancer in men,1 and the Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial (SELECT),2 it occurred to me that the negative results join a growing list of recently published randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on vitamins that have not confirmed what has been suggested via small and/or observational study data.
Physicians' Health Study Findings
"Vitamin E and C in the Prevention of Prostate and Total Cancer in Men"1 and "Vitamin E and C in the Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease in Men,"3 both published in JAMA, were RTCs done concurrently on 1,461 medical doctors ages 50 and older. The studies lasted 10 years and compared groups taking vitamin E (400 IU every other day), vitamin C (500 mg daily), vitamin E and C or a placebo. Neither study showed that either supplement (alone or in combination) reduced cancer risk, cardiovascular disease or all-cause mortality. [See Tables 1-3.]
| Table 1: Total All-Cause Mortality | ||
| Intervention | Subjects | Mortality |
| Vitamins C and E | 3,656 | 442 |
| Vitamin E, placebo C | 3,659 | 399 |
| Vitamin C, placebo E | 3,673 | 415 |
| Placebo | 3,653 | 405 |
| Table2: Cancer Risk | |||
| Intervention | Subjects | Total Cancers | Prostate Cancers |
| Vitamins C and E | 3,656 | 493 | 238 |
| Vitamin E, placebo C | 3,659 | 491 | 256 |
| Vitamin C, placebo E | 3,673 | 480 | 270 |
| Placebo | 3,653 | 479 | 245 |
| Table3: Cardiovascular Risk | |||
| Intervention | Subjects | Total Events | Fatal Events |
| Vitamins C and E | 3,656 | 310 | 127 |
| Vitamin E, placebo C | 3,659 | 310 | 131 |
| Vitamin C, placebo E | 3,673 | 309 | 129 |
| Placebo | 3,653 | 316 | 122 |
SELECT Findings
A total of 35,533 men in their 50s with low prostate specific antigen levels and negative digital rectal examinations from 427 locations qualified for the RCT known as "SELECT," findings from which were also published in JAMA. Of those men, 34, 888 were included in the primary analysis, making it the biggest cancer prevention RCT ever done. After five years of taking either 400 IU vitamin E plus 200 mcg selenium, 400 IU vitamin E plus placebo, 200 mcg selenium plus placebo or two placebo pills daily, the results [see Table 4] did not confirm what had been unexpected findings in earlier studies - including data derived from the famous beta carotene study on smokers, which discovered that vitamin E reduced prostate cancer in men who were heavy smokers. [See Andersen G.D. "Is Beta Carotene Safe?" Dynamic Chiropractic, Sept. 23, 1994. Article available online at [url=http://www.dynamicchiropractic.com.]]http://www.dynamicchiropractic.com.][/url]
| Table 4: Prostate Cancer Risk | ||
| Intervention | Subjects | Prostate Cancer |
| Vitamin E, selenium | 8,703 | 437 |
| Vitamin E, placebo selenium | 8,737 | 473 |
| Selenium, placebo E | 8,752 | 432 |
| Placebo E, placebo selenium | 8,752 | 416 |
Comment
Although these latest studies are disappointing, the findings reveal that isolated micronutrients found to be high in whole-food diets that do reduce cancer and cardiovascular disease rates do not work as stand-alone agents when they are studied in a way that greatly reduces the odds a result is a statistical anomaly. If you stop and think about it, entities as complex as cardiovascular disease and cancer are not the type of problems one would expect to be caused by a couple of micronutrient imbalances. Next month, we'll look at how B vitamins did in their large, recently published RCTs.
References
When I graduated from chiropractic college in 1981 and started practice, I heard it all, and very little was positive. “You are a quack; you do not know what a subluxation is; you couldn’t get into a real health care program, so you chose the one that is slightly above a mail-order degree; you have no proof that chiropractic works; Are you really licensed?”, and so much more.
| Digital Exclusive
A central challenge in creating our identity is that chiropractic is a method of care, not a technique or procedure. This is an important concept for us to promote. Our patients are treated with lifestyle modification, exercise, nutritional supplements, diet and a whole-body approach to accelerate the natural healing process. We are not simply CMT providers.
The results of a global survey released late last year (2023) unveiled some startling findings among medical and nursing students. The “Clinician of the Future: 2023 Education Edition” surveyed 2,212 students, of which 446 were in the United States, from 91 countries.
